NDP-Liberal deal fuels cautious optimism for climate file

Mar. 23, 2022

[Editor: Cautious optimism? Just another reminder that electoral politics isn't dealing with the climate emergency?]

A new agreement between the federal NDP and the Liberal government promises political stability until 2025, which will be key for climate action despite its underwhelming commitments, political scientists say.

On March 22, Prime Minister Justin Trudeau announced the Liberals had struck a deal with the federal NDP to govern until 2025, with the NDP agreeing to back the Liberals on confidence votes and budgets in exchange for action on dental and pharmacare, affordability and climate change, among other items.

“It's an important and positive step … we're more likely to get sustained action on climate change to the degree that we can build a robust, stable consensus within Parliament,” Maxwell Cameron, a professor of political science at the University of British Columbia, told Canada’s National Observer.

The agreement references climate actions that will be prioritized, including just transition legislation, the creation of a Clean Jobs Training Centre to support workers, home energy-efficiency programs, a phaseout of public financing for the fossil fuel sector and “measures to achieve significant emissions reductions by 2030 compared to 2005 levels.”

Green MP Mike Morrice told Canada’s National Observer he’s glad to see parliamentarians working together on the shared interests of Canadians and the potential for progress on dental and pharmacare, but noted the climate priorities in the agreement contain “very little, if anything” beyond the Liberals’ election commitments.

“In order to hold on to the possibility of (limiting global warming to) 1.5 C and follow the science on climate, we're going to need to do far more still,” said Morrice, citing things like the quick elimination of fossil fuel subsidies, ending new pipeline development, rejecting the proposed Bay du Nord offshore oil project and an immediate move towards renewable sources of energy.

He noted that whenever there is a confidence vote now, “all Liberal and NDP MPs will need to fall into line, and if we look at the Emergencies Act and vote as a recent example, there's a concern with how that could be used.”

Overall, Morrice said the agreement is “a step in the right direction, at least to ensure that parliamentarians take their jobs seriously and find a way to work together.”

Liberal MP Terry Duguid, parliamentary secretary to Environment and Climate Change Minister Steven Guilbeault, said this stability is going to be very important for hitting the federal government’s target of cutting greenhouse gas emissions 40 to 45 per cent below 2005 levels by 2030.

When it comes to alleviating and adapting to climate change, “I see a lot of co-operation on the climate front,” said Duguid. “And just speaking personally, there's no light between myself and many of my NDP colleagues from Manitoba on the need for serious climate action.”

Right now, the federal government has a lot of policies in the works, including new regulations on oil and gas emissions, methane emissions, zero-emission vehicles, a clean electricity standard and the soon-to-be-announced emissions reduction plan, Kathryn Harrison, a professor of political science at the University of British Columbia, told Canada’s National Observer.

A stable Parliament will allow those policy developments to proceed, which “is really important at this moment in Canadian climate policy,” Harrison said.

Though the cross-party collaboration is welcome, Harrison says the language of the agreement has “no teeth.”

For three of the five climate priorities, the agreement references “moving forward,” and without clear deadlines, that kind of language “doesn't give the NDP any leverage,” she said.

“These negotiations might call the NDP bluff in the 2021 election where they promised deeper (emissions) cuts but waffled on the Trans Mountain pipeline,” Harrison added. “They didn't bring forward a plan that could credibly meet their targets, and that didn't put them in a strong negotiating position.”

It also remains to be seen what this agreement means for the implementation of the Canadian Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act, she said.

When the Liberals bring forward their emissions reduction plan at the end of the month, opposition parties like the NDP, Bloc Québécois and Green Party will hold them to account and ask tough questions about the Liberals’ projections and timelines.

“One vague concern that I have is that the NDP have weakened their position in their ability to credibly push for more because they have signed off on supporting the government's climate initiatives without getting anything more,” said Harrison.

“They can ask questions, and presumably they will. But they no longer have a credible threat to pull the plug on the government on climate as long as it delivers on the measures that are in the confidence-and-supply agreement.”

In a press release, Climate Action Network Canada reiterated the importance of political stability and cross-party co-operation to speed up climate action in Canada, but emphasized the Liberal and NDP commitments fall short of Canada’s fair share of the global effort to limit warming to 1.5 C.

The release calls on the NDP to “use its increased presence at the table to expand its political imagination and push for more visionary climate action that meets the scale of the emergency.”

[Top photo: National Observer]